Skip to content

Posts from Mafia 29. Witch Hunt Auto-translated

Mafia Closed Topic
No ratings yet — be the first to rate!
In reply to Киц Кицунька
User Avatar
#347
Auto-translated
Kits Kitsunka
The pentagram was widely known as a protection against all evil... I found that out too. Maybe the Registrar - the Inquisitor - is really who he seems? But then, there's no point in eliminating the Templars. Those who are needed for their victory are dead, and we can interact with them in the town. Or not? At night, they don't do anything for the town, unfortunately, but they might be needed during the daytime vote. And could the Executioner be resurrected, or maybe we can persuade them? We really need him... And why was I even put on the list of marshals?
Emm... What? If the Inquisitor is dead, we lose. If the Inquisitor is dead, the Templars will win as soon as we eliminate the last Mafia member. Not "if the Inquisitor is dead, there's no point in eliminating the Templars." You're a little confused.



Even if we fight, even if there’s such thing
I will not give up
Just like this, I won't let go
Strongly grasping your right hand’s warmth
I’ll be here
User Avatar
#348
Auto-translated
"And the main question: why did you ignore me and not answer, what role do you think Reg has?"
And I don't know his role for sure, I just said that he doesn't necessarily have to be an occultist, there's no need to be so sure about it, because the pentagram has many meanings :)
Что такое осень - это небо
Плачущее небо под ногами
In reply to Gil4
User Avatar
#349
Auto-translated
Gil4
Hmm... What? If Ink is dead, we lose. If Ink is dead, the Templars will win as soon as we eliminate the last Mafia member. Not "if Ink is dead, there's no point in eliminating the Templars." You're a little confused.
I didn't fully understand the rules... thanks, I didn't know that.
In reply to Mestear
User Avatar
#350
Auto-translated
Aves
It's not universally applicable, by the way; that's an overstatement, and I explained why. But I can write it again if you really need me to.
From day one, I suspected Gur Adept and tried to have him executed on the first, second, and third days, as you can see. Why? Simply because there's no one else to attribute that clue to, and, in my opinion, it looks quite compelling: "La Commedia --> Commedia dell'Arte, the 'comedy of masks.' Slonish wrote about this, and Gur has a quote in his signature from the movie 'The Mask' - 'Amazing! With this power, I can become a superhero. I can fight crime, protect the innocent, bring peace to the world! But first...' And what genre is 'The Mask'? That's right, a comedy. And as I wrote, I was also a suspect, but according to you, I'm a Magister. Fine, you don't like the clue, but what about the murder itself? Hermit has a bloody inscription scratched on his forehead, and in Adept's picture, claws are piercing his skin, and blood is flowing from underneath... In my opinion, it's all very, very beautiful.
Okay, I'm tired of arguing. Let others say what they think, and we'll decide who to send the Thief to, Gur or TaKo.
And yes, there is something interesting. "Sweet Tooth" from TaKo's profile. Chalk in the hand of the Registrar. Of course, this could be considered part of the clue ("he drew a pentagram with chalk"), but it can also be interpreted differently. Nebo could have simply written, "a pentagram was drawn on the wall of the Registrar, presumably by the victim." But he specifically mentioned the chalk. Is this still a clue pointing to TaKo? And is Reg then a Demon Worshipper drawing his diabolical symbol? Perhaps a Prophet. After all, a Prophet foretells the coming of the Antichrist, i.e., communicates with higher powers. A pentagram is needed to summon these forces. This also aligns with the "heretic" status.

Added 3 minutes ago
Kits Kitsunka
I didn't fully understand the rules... thank you, I didn't know that.
You're welcome. :)
The Templars win when:
1. The Inquisitor is dead.
2. The Bishop is dead.
3. All the Mafia are dead.
Just in case, so everyone understands for sure. :) The Bishop is already dead, and only half of the Mafia remain - as soon as the Inquisitor dies, we will almost certainly be unable to do anything if we don't eliminate at least one Templar.



Even if we fight, even if there’s such thing
I will not give up
Just like this, I won't let go
Strongly grasping your right hand’s warmth
I’ll be here
In reply to Gil4
User Avatar
#351
Auto-translated
Gil4
Alright, I'm tired of arguing, let others say what they think, and let's decide who to send the Thief to, Guru or TaKo.
And yes, there is something interesting. "Sweet tooth" from TaKo's profile. Chalk in the Registrar's hand. Of course, this could be considered part of the clue ("drew a pentagram with chalk"), but it can also be interpreted differently. The author could have simply written "a pentagram was drawn on the Registrar's wall, apparently belonging to the deceased." But he specifically mentioned the chalk. Is this a clue, an indication of TaKo? And is the Registrar then a demon worshiper drawing his diabolical symbol? A Prophet, for example. A Prophet, after all, foretells the coming of the Antichrist, i.e., communicates with higher powers. A pentagram is needed to summon these forces that everyone understands. It also coincides with the "heretic" status.
No need to get tired, I think the other players, after reading my interpretation of the clues, will draw their own conclusions. Your opinion is already clear, but still, agree that it's not a fact that you are not a demon worshiper, so it would be foolish to draw conclusions based only on your judgments. :)
Regarding the Registrar, drawing with white chalk? A diabolical pentagram? (If we consider it as such) doesn't seem to fit very well. Why not draw the pentagram with blood? But specifically, with white chalk... It's still difficult to say anything concrete about this. Therefore, I'm not sure that he is an occultist, at least not in my opinion.
I think this pointless argument can be stopped. :)
Что такое осень - это небо
Плачущее небо под ногами
User Avatar
#352
Auto-translated
You think Taco is a Demon Worshipper that the Hunter won't be able to kill, right?
Yes, she might be a prophet, and that would just be a wasted turn for the Hunter. It's better to check someone else then. I just don't understand who Register is. It's a great idea by Nebula to separate the Mafia into occultists and demon worshippers: they kill the same way, and the hints about their roles are the same.
Overall, I think he's a Warlock, because the Antichrist always slits everyone's throats, and there's no indication of a "fork in the heart" in the newspaper, so Taco is a prophet, and she was blocked, and again, I don't see a non-killing Neutral Demon Worshipper, and therefore the Hunter won't be able to kill her. But we have two clues for the Warlock, and I can't connect either of them to Register.
Morni, if you're afraid that Taco is innocent (because she's a Demon Worshipper), let's have the Thief go to her at the same time as the Hunter goes to the Witch. I'm very skeptical about Gure-Adept anyway. If she's innocent, the Thief won't let her kill, and we'll even get an extra kill on the next night.
I basically agree with this, it's a good idea, I hope the Thief won't ignore the daytime drama on the tribune. If he doesn't want to try out the stolen Neutral role.

I can execute Aves, but there are two nuances. First, will the other players support this execution? Because "executing the Resurrector from the second, so to speak, city" sounds scary to someone who hasn't understood the situation.
Secondly, the Marshal will get the Neutral role of the Magister, NEBKO, that is, he will get resurrection and silence? Will he then be able to resurrect his Magister, and what then? Will the Neutral role only be with him, or will it return to the Magister? I hope they won't both have resurrection
My sword, my trusted ally, unphased by my aspect.
User Avatar
#353
Auto-translated
Morni, I'll address one nuance – you can't resurrect the executed. Therefore, you need to EXECUTE the Magister.



Even if we fight, even if there’s such thing
I will not give up
Just like this, I won't let go
Strongly grasping your right hand’s warmth
I’ll be here
User Avatar
#354
Auto-translated
I hope they don’t both have resurrection?
No, they won’t.
Небо – мольбы не ждёт
Небо – угроз не слышит
Небо – ведёт особый счёт
Небо – тебя найдёт

По вопросам модерации: nebov24@gmail.com
User Avatar
#355
Auto-translated
And, well, the second nuance simply disappears on its own.



Even if we fight, even if there’s such thing
I will not give up
Just like this, I won't let go
Strongly grasping your right hand’s warmth
I’ll be here
User Avatar
#356
Auto-translated
Ah, right. Yes, I forgot, and that changes everything. Execute Avis. And I still think the thief should go see Taco.
My sword, my trusted ally, unphased by my aspect.
In reply to Happy Life
User Avatar
#357
Auto-translated
Morning
Ah, right. Yes, I forgot, that changes everything. Execute Avis. And I still think the thief should go see Taco.
Aives*) :rolleyes:
Что такое осень - это небо
Плачущее небо под ногами
User Avatar
#358
Auto-translated
Execute Eaves - 2 votes (Gil4, Morning)

6 votes are needed for the execution.
Небо – мольбы не ждёт
Небо – угроз не слышит
Небо – ведёт особый счёт
Небо – тебя найдёт

По вопросам модерации: nebov24@gmail.com
User Avatar
#359
Auto-translated
I really wanted to write like Nebko did on the first day: rolleyes:
It's extremely amusing.
My sword, my trusted ally, unphased by my aspect.
In reply to Happy Life
User Avatar
#360
Auto-translated
And Vis,

Locky, are you, by any chance, a member of the Mafia yourself?
Tomorrow holds no promises
Except the ones we've made
User Avatar
#361
Auto-translated
WisTrit
And Wis,

Locky, are you by any chance a mafia member yourself?
Yes, he's definitely a mafia member because if the chalk and pentagram are clues pointing to the role of Registrar (was he a sorcerer?), then it means that the only clue to the murderer can be that the Registrar was bleeding (Stop bleeding and fight back!).
Всё не так плохо как Вы думаете. Всё намного хуже!