With disapproval,
Slonysh.
New here? I'm Roha — want a quick tour?
This is the most important thing: don't doubt your decision, no matter what it is.
Gil4, there was an example given in the situation with the Witch. In Mafia 12, I think. Yes, they didn't write a modkill there. Here's the same situation, just with a slightly different premise.

Actually, the modkill was implemented at the insistence of the offended Cash because the Sorceress was putting too much emphasis on her own role in the discussions, as presented in the newspapers. So, there's no need to talk about any mitigating circumstances here.
And if the GM doesn't take into account the opinions of all players on any aspect of the game management, then it's already a GM-overlord situation and all sorts of nonsense.
