Posts from Mafia 27. The problem of Bovblob residents Auto-translated

The town won, largely thanks to Arandor, who immediately revealed his role and status (by the way, he didn't reveal his status correctly) :D :D :D, and even I realized he was a Unicorn. The Mafia's mistake was that they didn't kill him on the first night :D :D :D. After that, it was too late :) Also, we were lucky that the Hatter immediately found our Puppeteer, and Hostor revealed his Masked Man, and the Mafia believed it and killed him. After we executed Kostyan as Mr. Death, besides Arandor with a "-" status, only the Mafia remained (I didn't think I would make it to the end of the game). Fortunately, Morning somehow figured out my role, and I also started to suspect that he was the General. I correctly suspected Registr of being Mafia and wrote about his negative status, but Ple-Sen seemed like the Ringmaster to me; I wouldn't have suspected Deriel. Also, Toria didn't decide to investigate soon enough because the sausages shoved him into a room, shouting "Danger," and I thought the General's protection had activated or something... In general, I enjoyed the Mafia game, but I didn't like the rather irresponsible attitude of many of the participants – one replacement after another. I think that before signing up, you should think carefully about whether you will have the time, and if you do decide to sign up, you should play. Well, I initially thought Arandor was innocent based on his behavior, but in the middle of the game, the clue "silent-screaming" fit him so well that I voted against him, and then I was very surprised that Registr turned out to be an Acrobat, not an Illusionist, because the clue "silent" with his signature applied to him; how can it apply to a Lizard??? Thanks to everyone for the game, and of course, to the GM! Original setting.

The game is quite good. But I'm just, really, getting tired of playing as the "bad guys." Not a single city role in all the games. IMHO, it's not a good idea to show the "checkers" in the newspaper.

Added after 3 minutes
If someone wants to play as the "bad guys," take number 16, or at least number 8.

Thorium, maf - it’s fate.

A vivid, expressive, memorable, and unique example of how easily you can ruin a Mafia game, even with such a strong lineup.
Vegtam, Gur, Dariel – who are these guys?

Overall, I enjoyed the game. The town won, but it was largely due to luck, which I didn't particularly like. The most important thing was the Hive losing the Clown. By losing their main and only weapon against the General, the Hive essentially lost.
Hermi impressed me with his investigations (I even checked if he was lying about the status, which is what I wanted from the Artist, but he figured it out himself without me even having to say anything :)). Mon had some pretty good reasoning, and the same goes for Ara (although to a lesser extent, he was sometimes inattentive :D). Also, regarding Ara, the misdirection of the status played into our hands, of course, but... It also made the game easier, which reduced the challenge. And I actually like it when the difficulty is higher. That's why I don't understand the Hive teams that simply eliminate one of the strong players on the first night – it just makes the game less interesting... But that's just my opinion. Neira successfully exposed Hosa. TaKo impressed me by not siding with Mon and not healing the Vegetable, despite his request. I was afraid that if the player controlling the Vegetable didn't think about the request and just decided to fulfill it, the investigation would be lost (there's no point in healing the General – then Mon would definitely be exposed, and the Clown would go kill the General anyway. The Vegetable can't be healed by the Clown). Of course, this loss of the investigation wouldn't have played a significant role, but... It's nice when players think and don't blindly follow others. Ple-sena, I want to commend you for the investigation on the night of my death – I ensured his alibi with my plan (Hermi, I wrote everything clearly in the note, how could you have overlooked his Mafia status? The status is "town," and the only Mafia member with that status is the Monkey, so the Monkey killed him, and I was hiding from Ple-sena – he was becoming 100% the Grammophone, which is what I wanted to prove with my investigation (or survive if I was wrong about him)). And he, in turn, unintentionally played along with my plan and proved the role of the Tamer 100% (and even then, they didn't immediately understand – the Artist compared them, the Grammophone followed him and didn't expose him during the murder – i.e., he's neither the Artist nor the Grammophone nor the Monkey. That left only the Tamer, but for some reason, they overlooked the fact that the Grammophone was following the Monkey). So, Ple-sena, thank you for that "tandem" at the end of the game.
The Hive's actions were largely unclear and still are – there were better options available. I hope I just didn't see the logic, but it was there. Gamayun, why blame everything on Gur? He was eliminated not on the first night, and not even on the second. Later, yes, I agree, the game was almost 100% lost, but they could still have fought (and, in general, they should have). He let you down badly, of course, but... I wasn't happy about his modkill either, to be honest. The interest faded when we were left with such a protected role. You too, as I saw. By the way, I'm too lazy to wait for the log. On nights 3 and 4, did the Acrobats attempt to kill me a second time, or not?
By the way, this is the second game, and again, there's a double voice role. :D Thanks to everyone for the game. :)

If you read my post carefully, it becomes clear that Gur is not the only one who caused me some confusion.

The monstrous demise of my pink brother as well as the fact that the second brother turned out to be blue undermined my strength, exhausted my brain activity, and plunged me into a deep sorrow, which deprived me of all analytical abilities.

Thank you for the merciful death; you can keep the kidney, it's in good condition — I hardly drink beer in the winter.

If you read my post carefully, it becomes clear that Gur is not the only one who caused some confusion on my part.

Where does this hidden hostility in your posts directed at me come from? :) I didn't make a mistake accusing you of acrobatics. Did I offend you somehow? If so, I apologize.
Yes, Gur is not the only one, but the Monkey didn't influence the game for very long. And even if she had been modkilled, it wouldn't have hindered you as much as the modkill of the Clown. That's why I didn't take Vegtama into account in my post – he didn't hinder your strong team that much.
By the way, thank you for reminding me. Tako, and I apologize to you for the mistaken accusation of being a Mafia member when you came in as a replacement. The role didn't play a part in that accusation, but still – I shouldn't have relied so much on the description in the newspaper.

Thanks to everyone for the game. I enjoyed it overall, except for a few things. First, Arandor **violated** the rules, and there's no other way to put it. We're not playing a psychological mafia game where such moves are allowed. Second, Hostor revealed my role. I think that only a foolish person, or someone who wasn't paying attention to the game, wouldn't have guessed my role after his post. I also believe that this shouldn't happen in future games (by the way, after that, I saw no other option than to skip my turn to try to make someone else a suspect). Third, I'm against replacing players with those who have already been eliminated.

Third, I am against replacing players with those who have already been eliminated.

I fully support this idea.

This also applies to Ara (though to a lesser extent; he was sometimes a bit careless in his reasoning).

I was just relaxed, bro :cool: and having fun playing, as always :smile09:

Seriously though, yes. I sometimes forgot about certain details. For example, I initially thought that the gramophone goes to the victim, and if the victim is killed, the killer is identified. That's why from day one, I considered Plesen to be the gramophone, because I asked for protection, and he might be the only one who would come to my aid. I expressed this right after the newspaper incident, saying that the protection was strange, because I had forgotten how the Night Watchman works. But this actually helped me in compiling the list, although in the middle of the game, I started to doubt his innocence, but it didn't last long. I think Morninga was figured out right away, and so was Doc Kayla-TaKo, after the second night. I also wondered who the Jester was, choosing between Gil and Liz (I had already found a role for Plesen). But after Gamayun's execution, I relaxed and almost 100% believed Gil, who actually did almost all the work, although he sometimes made mistakes :P
By the way, it's sometimes very useful to write down who you suspect is innocent. I suspected Hermit for half the game, and many others suspected him too, maybe that's why the Mafia kept him alive, and he turned out to be such a useful role.

I am generally against substitutions; I am in favor of active participation from everyone who signs up. If you sign up, please play. :D Of course, unforeseen situations can occur, but it is important to treat the registration process responsibly.

Added 3 minutes later
Ar, Ple-sen is not the only one who would have come. :D And yes, I was wrong. I have already apologized for the main mistake of accusing TaKo. Fortunately, this mistake did not affect anything.

Added 3 minutes later
Mafy, respond, were you trying to kill me with Acrobats on the third and fourth nights with the second kill? I'm curious! :D

It was a real shame when characters like the Puppeteer and the Man in the Mask were eliminated so early in the game. I really wanted the Puppeteer to cause some chaos, something I couldn't do as a vampire, but it seems it wasn't meant to be.

Manics just don't have luck, huh.

Added 15 minutes later

Hossi, Kostyan and I will have the same status. There's no point in comparing.

If I wrote: "there's no point in comparing" or "it's pointless to compare, we'll just waste the night," would that be considered revealing information?
Or if I had a good status or was a Mafia member?

Initially, I wanted to thoroughly and logically analyze the game, dissect it... Express a few not-so-pleasant opinions about a couple of individuals who disappointed me with their actions (with arguments, of course), but now everything seems less important, because everyone will simply not care about my opinion and my complaints. Enough said. "Thank you for the game."