Mafia 26. Lady Mallowen's Last Caprice — Mafia

Gil4

15 years ago

Auto-translated

TaKo, and thank you too. :) You played well. And I would also accept "myself" as the answer for "mana" based on that logic; I also have a habit of twisting everything into such ingenious interpretations, which seem very beautiful and, at the same time, are not real solutions to the clues. Both you and I messed up with the "maniac." I stubbornly couldn't find such obvious things.

In reply to Gil4

Ta Kotoraya...

15 years ago

Auto-translated

Gil4

TaKo, and thank you too. :) You played well. And I would have also accepted "myself" as the answer for the murderer, based on that logic. I also have a habit of twisting everything into such "genius" interpretations, which seem very beautiful and fitting, but aren't actually real solutions to the clues. We both messed up with the murderer. We stubbornly couldn't find such obvious things.

No... I didn't play very well... I didn't have enough time. And I was obviously giving myself away in the discussion:o But winning is the main thing.
And about the "genius" interpretations - well, there weren't any such obvious things here, agree? Many people had clues that could point to the murderer... And that's good!! Otherwise, the murderer always has the most noticeable role - killing every night, clues accumulate. They are quickly figured out.

And I was convinced once again - doctor is a cursed role:rolleyes:

Gil4

15 years ago

Auto-translated

I suspected him on the second day when Ara wanted to execute him – that’s when I almost confirmed my suspicions.
The first day – no obvious clues (for me, I didn’t watch the Sherlock Holmes movie and, I confess, I didn’t read the novel on which the film with Guinness was based. I couldn’t find the clover because I didn’t know which anime the avatar of Flandre was from. Otherwise, I must say that it wasn’t extremely difficult, but not obvious either). The second day – an obvious clue pointing to Mana, not so easy to find, but an obvious clue pointing to Jane. The third day – an obvious clue pointing to Mana, which is not surprising considering his death, and an obvious clue from the GM pointing to Charles. The matryoshka was a good clue, yes. And with the doctor, it was tough. In my first two games (including the previous one, observation was still involved), and in both, the doctor died on the very first night.

In reply to Gil4

Ta Kotoraya...

15 years ago

Auto-translated

Gil4

I was exposed on the second day when Ara wanted to execute me – that's when I almost confirmed my suspicions.
On the first day, there were no obvious clues (for me, I didn't watch the Sherlock Holmes movie and, I confess, I didn't read the novel on which the Guinness adaptation was based. I couldn't find the clover because I didn't know which anime Flandre's avatar was from). Overall, I'd say it wasn't overly difficult, but not obvious either. On the second day, there was an obvious clue about Mana, not so easy to find, but an obvious clue about Jane. On the third day, there was an obvious clue about Mana, which is not surprising considering his death, and an obvious clue from the GM about Charles. The matryoshka doll was a good clue, yes. And the doctor... it was tough. In my first two Mafia games (including the previous one, where I was observing), the doctor died on the first night in both.

That's what I'm saying... I was exposed... Hos defended me on the first day – he was exposed. But the town wasn't very active, which is why we lost =)).

By the way, speaking of being exposed, you can check out the 11th Mafia game. There was a lot of exposure there!! :) Both mine and Kyle's... But we still won.

Gil4

15 years ago

Auto-translated

You forgot to consider that Ar also tried to shift the blame onto you on the second day, knowing that I had already convinced some people of his guilt, and there definitely wouldn't be enough votes for your execution. That was the final factor.

Added 2 minutes later
By the way, it's a shame I didn't stage a small performance. I had an idea to find a brilliant Berber who would accuse you (I can find them even among those who are completely innocent :D) and suddenly shift everyone's attention to the fact that you had killed someone at least once. It would have been fun to watch Ar's reaction.

In reply to Gil4

Ta Kotoraya...

15 years ago

Auto-translated

Gil4

You also forgot to consider that Ar tried to shift the blame onto you on the second day, knowing that I had already convinced some people of his guilt, and there definitely wouldn't be enough votes for your execution. That was the final factor.

Added 2 minutes later
By the way, it's a shame I didn't stage a small performance. I had the idea to find a brilliant Barbarian to accuse you (I can find one even for someone who is completely innocent :D) and suddenly shift everyone's attention to the fact that you killed someone at least once. It would have been fun to watch Ar's reaction.

He would have betrayed me... we agreed on this on the first day. This would have been his alibi - because his role was more important than mine. And we had made a decision in advance about my sacrifice - just in case. Well, he saw that he was being accused and would definitely be executed - and he tried to defend me - for the future. IMHO, we all did everything right! I could have supported his execution to further protect myself, but there was a problem with the timing - I couldn't get online in time.

Пандора

15 years ago

Auto-translated

Ar was also going to execute TaKo, if I remember correctly... just to create a diversion:rolleyes:

By the way, I also started taking care of my role after the 3rd night as much as I could:D. What kind of evidence did they have against me...? Did Slonish decide to get revenge on me for being so active?))) Or redeem herself for the evidence against Gur?)))

Gil4

15 years ago

Auto-translated

Yes, it’s a good combination. Just a small note: that’s what I was thinking of doing. :D

In reply to Пандора

Ta Kotoraya...

15 years ago

Auto-translated

Pandora

Ar himself was going to execute TaKo, if I'm not mistaken... Just to create a diversion:rolleyes:

Exactly!
We agreed on this right away, because my role wasn't super important. (or rather, it was important - but the defenders were killed, and it became unimportant). Despite having 2 kills, Gur had an important attribute - he was inconspicuous in the game :) Pandora and Hossi shouldn't have been lost at all. That left me - which, in general, was logical. It was a calculated move - nothing more.

Gil4

15 years ago

Auto-translated

The thing is, we would have executed TaKo on the second day, and Ara, as before, on the third. We would have likely won. I revealed Guru and you, Pandora. The worlds would have simply executed you according to my will, which I wrote so carefully, and all that would remain would be to figure out Hos. There is, however, a problem – Hos is good enough to convince one of the remaining two worlds that he is right. But still, there was a good chance of winning.

Arandor

15 years ago

Auto-translated

He would crush me.

Without a second thought.

Пандора

15 years ago

Auto-translated

The thing is, we executed TaKo on the second day, while Ara, as before, on the third. We might have actually won.

That's exactly what I'm talking about! What if... :D The city clearly lost.

In reply to Пандора

Слоныш

15 years ago

Auto-translated

Pandora

What kind of evidence did you have against me... Did Slonysh decide to get revenge on me for my activity?))) Or is she trying to redeem herself for the evidence against Gura?)))

Balance your build, plus the mana balance is severely skewed due to "luck," to put it mildly. Finishing too quickly isn't good either.