Skip to content

Posts from 1st annual offline tournament "Best Of The Best"

5.0 (6 ratings)
In reply to Ta Kotoraya...
User Avatar
#92
Auto-translated
I still don't understand. The tournament is called "Best of the Best" in Russian. Let's say they approve 2 or 3 difficulty levels. Let's say 3. Players A, B, and C each take first place on their respective difficulty levels. And who is the best among them? And if the players on the difficult level are much stronger, wouldn't the player who took second place there be better than the two who took first place on the easier levels? How will this be determined? And if you also tie in a rating system, it will become a complete sham, not "Best of the Best." Most likely, the nomination on the easier level should be called "Best of the Bad" because I am more than sure that strong players, or those who want to consider themselves strong and test their skills, will play on Impossible.

Added 5 minutes later
Ta Kotoraya...;45235
(if there is a tough choice between Normal and Impossible) I probably won't let myself play - it's embarrassing:o

I'll have to choose - either a high place or a clear conscience:D

So that no one is embarrassed and no one's conscience is troubled, you need to agree on one difficulty level. You almost understand this, but you can't formulate it?
In reply to Ta Kotoraya...
User Avatar
#93
Auto-translated
Ta Kotoraya...;45235
Hmm... I still think it's better not to choose a difficulty level in advance... Just because, for example, I probably won't allow myself to play only on the easy level (if there's a tough choice between normal and impossible) - I'd be embarrassed:o But I don't think I'll get a high ranking on impossible...
I understand you perfectly... Just think about this: if you think you won't get a high ranking on impossible, then you won't on easy either! Because those who "will" get high rankings on impossible will take all the top spots on the easy level too... You're paving the way for them! :) And the fact that you suggest giving only one award per person, regardless of the number of saves, won't save the situation. Strong players will take the top spots in both categories...

Of course, they'll thank you, but do you really need that?... In fact, the ideal option is a third difficulty level, and one for everyone.
IronAxe;45243
So that no one feels ashamed or has a guilty conscience - we need to agree on one difficulty level. You've almost understood this, but you can't articulate it?
No, it's been said, Solomon! :D "All are equal, but some are more equal than others!"
Сначала было слово...
FizMiG v.2.0 *** Очередное обновление справочника! *** http://vk.com/fizmig

In reply to IronAxe
User Avatar
#94
Auto-translated
IronAxe;45243
To avoid embarrassment and guilt, you need to agree on the same difficulty level. You almost understand this, but can't articulate it?
No, there are players of different levels on the forum! I think that 1 nomination is not enough in any case! And for those who haven't participated in tournaments at all (I was like that recently), it's simply PSYCHOLOGICALLY difficult to play immediately with pros on difficult levels!!! So, IMHO, there should be 2-3 nominations...
Если тебе не везёт в жизни, - играй в какую-нибудь другую игру:rolleyes:
Лидер клана "Из многих единое"

Приключения – это сплошные неприятности, только про них почему-то потом интересно вспоминать...
User Avatar
#95
Auto-translated
Good day!

I regret that I cannot participate MORE ACTIVELY in this heated DISCUSSION than I would like...:(

I simply don't have enough time... and it's unlikely to free up in the next week...

But I also CANNOT miss it!;)

"IronAxe" - I can tell you that your statements have started to take on the COLORS OF AGGRESSION!:(
When I mentioned the award for participants in the "Ta Kotoraya..." tournaments, I meant that those who are AFRAID to play on the highest difficulty level should think about it, ESPECIALLY IN TOURNAMENTS!!!
I said the word AWARD - not with the idea that it should be IMMEDIATELY given to someone, but with the idea that IT SHOULD BE USED AS AN EXAMPLE FOR EVERYONE!!!

And after that, how can you even dare to say: "We need to catch up and overtake other portals"
And you suggest that we catch up with them by playing on the Easy difficulty level???
You must be confused or simply unaware of what is happening on other portals!

And we will definitely talk about the Soviet Union later!:D:D:D

Since we're on the subject - I SUGGEST:
Stick to one difficulty level, but AWARD the 3 BEST!
Then there will only be 3 awards.

Because - this is not right: first there were 5 awards, and then they decided to make 6...
In my opinion, we need to move in a different direction!

Sincerely,
Prorock.

Как много в жизни есть путей
Для добродетелей и мира.


Я вернулся...
User Avatar
#97
Auto-translated
Guys, I'll say it again – I'm against having only one nomination! It's fundamentally wrong, in my opinion. And there's nothing to award me for (although thanks to the Prophet ;) ). Yes, it was psychologically challenging for me to play. But overall, I'm just an average player, although better than many... it's just extremely difficult to compete with real pros right away.
Если тебе не везёт в жизни, - играй в какую-нибудь другую игру:rolleyes:
Лидер клана "Из многих единое"

Приключения – это сплошные неприятности, только про них почему-то потом интересно вспоминать...
User Avatar
#98
Auto-translated
AmberSoler;45254
Invite me too! I was there as well!:D

Definitely!
I'll create a separate thread in the General Discussion forum at the end of the month, and we can talk there:D ;)

But this is still off-topic, gentlemen...

Getting back to the topic - I've made my final suggestion, and now it's up to you.

IN ANY CASE, I WILL TRY TO PARTICIPATE!

Sincerely,
Prorock.

Как много в жизни есть путей
Для добродетелей и мира.


Я вернулся...
In reply to Ta Kotoraya...
User Avatar
#99
Auto-translated
Ta Kotoraya...;45257
Guys, I'll say it again – I'm against having just one nomination! I think it's fundamentally wrong. And there's nothing to reward me for (although thanks to the Prophet ;) ). Yes, it was psychologically difficult for me to play. But overall, I'm just an average player, but better than many... it's just extremely difficult to compete with real pros right away.
I don't understand one thing. You said that your conscience wouldn't allow you to play on a difficulty level lower than Impossible... So, in any case, we'll see you there, right? Then why do you need another nomination? That's the first thing.

And secondly, we're not talking about the number of nominations – one or two isn't that critical. We're talking about the number of saves from one player. If you allow sending them to all nominations, it will still be "as if there was only one nomination"... With the same success, after the game is over (everyone plays in the nomination they want), you can put everyone in one table and see the result... Regardless of who played where... (although, in my opinion, it will be interesting... :) )
Сначала было слово...
FizMiG v.2.0 *** Очередное обновление справочника! *** http://vk.com/fizmig

In reply to Prorock
User Avatar
#100
Auto-translated
Prorock;45262
Returning to the topic – I have made my last offer, and now it is up to you to decide.

IN ANY CASE, I WILL TRY TO PARTICIPATE!
+1! I have also expressed my opinion... And I will definitely participate in any case! ;)

Added 1 minute ago
AmberSoler;45263
I don't understand one thing. You said that your conscience wouldn't allow you to play at a difficulty level lower than Impossible... So, in any case, we will see you there, right? Then why do you need another nomination?
Hmm... let's say that if I had a choice of 3 nominations, for example, or I could send saves to all 3 nominations, that would be the optimal option for me. That's what I meant...



P.S. And in general, I'm not just speaking for myself... there are people who are AFRAID to participate in Tournaments or are shy or something else... It will be easier for them... and I am just a separate case ;)
Если тебе не везёт в жизни, - играй в какую-нибудь другую игру:rolleyes:
Лидер клана "Из многих единое"

Приключения – это сплошные неприятности, только про них почему-то потом интересно вспоминать...
User Avatar
#102
Auto-translated
Please help me! I'm confused! Where can I find the link to submit an application to participate in this tournament? Don't let me remain in ignorance...
Мудрость должна найти применение в твоей жизни,иначе она заржавеет,как меч,который ни разу не пустили в дело.
Первооткрывательница,советник по делам мира Клана "E pluribus unum":rolleyes:

In reply to Svercha
User Avatar
#103
Auto-translated
Svercha;45285
Please help me! I'm confused! Where can I find the link to submit an application to participate in this tournament? Don't let me die in ignorance...
Submit your application in this thread. You can find all the information about the tournament and its organization in the first post of the thread. I hope you will participate - the more, the better!
Если тебе не везёт в жизни, - играй в какую-нибудь другую игру:rolleyes:
Лидер клана "Из многих единое"

Приключения – это сплошные неприятности, только про них почему-то потом интересно вспоминать...
In reply to Ta Kotoraya...
User Avatar
#104
Auto-translated
Ta Kotoraya...;45264
Hmm... let's say that if I had a choice of 3 nominations, or if I could submit saves for all 3 nominations, that would be the optimal option for me. That's what I meant...
:) You've convinced me!

Predicting the outcome:
20 participants... 5 nominations... 20 saves in each nomination... :D The places are assigned, the prizes are received...

That's it, I won't argue anymore...
Сначала было слово...
FizMiG v.2.0 *** Очередное обновление справочника! *** http://vk.com/fizmig

In reply to AmberSoler
User Avatar
#105
Auto-translated
AmberSoler;45287
:) You convinced me!

My prediction:
20 participants... 5 nominations... 20 saves in each nomination... :D The places are distributed, the prizes are received...

That's it, I won't argue anymore...
:D :D :D :D :D I won't argue anymore either! And I wasn't arguing before - I was just saying what I think... But your arguments turned out to be convincing:D Nevertheless, I insist - there should NOT be 1 nomination! IMHO, IMHO, and once again IMHO ;)
Если тебе не везёт в жизни, - играй в какую-нибудь другую игру:rolleyes:
Лидер клана "Из многих единое"

Приключения – это сплошные неприятности, только про них почему-то потом интересно вспоминать...
User Avatar
#106
Auto-translated
Please register me for the tournament if it’s not too late.
Мудрость должна найти применение в твоей жизни,иначе она заржавеет,как меч,который ни разу не пустили в дело.
Первооткрывательница,советник по делам мира Клана "E pluribus unum":rolleyes:

In reply to Prorock
User Avatar
#107
Auto-translated
Prorock;45251
"IronAxe" - I can tell you that your statements have started to reek of AGGRESSION!:(
This is when I suggest that everyone plays on a medium difficulty level so that no one feels bad and everyone receives a certificate as a memento of the tournament, stating that they participated, took a certain place, and were noted for their will to win, courage, or description. Yes, there's aggression on your face :)
Prorock;45251

And after that, how can you even dare to say: "We need to catch up and overtake other portals"
And you suggest that we catch up with them by playing on an Easy difficulty level??? You must be confusing something or you're completely unaware of what's happening on other portals!
Yes, indeed. When did I suggest playing on an easy difficulty level? Please provide a link. And you advise me to play tournaments without worrying too much - in that case, I definitely won't catch up with anyone. And as for the fact that I don't know what's happening on other portals, that's just ridiculous.
Prorock;45251

And we will definitely talk about the Soviet Union again!:D:D:D
What's the point? Well, if you want, we can.
Prorock;45251

If we're talking about it - I SUGGEST:
Stick to one difficulty level, but AWARD the 3 BEST!
Aren't AmberSoler and I suggesting the same thing?

Added after 10 minutes
Ta Kotoraya...;45264
P.S. And in general, I'm not just speaking for myself... there are people who are AFRAID to participate in tournaments or are embarrassed or something else... It will be easier for them this way...

Are you saying it will be easier for them to become the best? And they aren't afraid to be last in the nomination on the easy difficulty level.
User Avatar
#108
Auto-translated
Of course, one nomination would provide a reasonably objective assessment of the participants' strengths, but if someone decides to participate, say, at the 130% level, and then they are told that one nomination is worth 200%, while they could only manage 160% with great difficulty, playing on impossible difficulty might become a torment for them (nothing works despite all their efforts), and they might not even finish the game. There should still be 2 (or more) nominations, and each person should decide for themselves where to participate. An analogy with tennis comes to mind: an athlete chooses which tournament to go to, where the opponents are weaker (and the prize money is smaller) and the probability of winning is higher, or where the opponents are stronger but the chances of winning are low – but the tournament is more prestigious. It is difficult to say which is better – winning a tournament of category 1 or, for example, reaching the quarter-finals in a Grand Slam tournament (although there is a ranking system there, but it is also conditional and gives an idea of the strength of the players when considering a large number of tournaments). So, the problem of objectively assessing the strength of players at different game difficulties arises not only in HOMM, and it is solved in different ways, but there is no ideal solution. My opinion: 2 nominations, and each person will decide for themselves where to send their only save file. And I would also like to know if anyone will play below 200%? Because if no one does, then all this discussion loses its meaning. Personally, I will play at 200%.

Statistics

Welcome our newest member: artem