Posts from Reports on online games and their confirmations (Winter 2009-10 season).

Winter Game
Looser (red, Rampart, Kirr, Kirr) def Sevan_80 (blue, Stronghold, Gundula, Gundula) 2sm4d(3), 127

Excellent start, lots of money, horses in the castle, a secondary Dungeon, two cons (3+1), and on the second turn, teleport to the enemy.
Thank you for the game.

Winter game
Looser (red, Rampart, Kirr, Kirr) def Sevan_80 (blue, Stronghold, Gundula, Gundula) 2sm4d(3), 127

Great start, lots of money, horses in the castle, a secondary Dungeon, two cons (3+1), and on the second turn, teleport to the enemy.
Thanks for the game.

Confirmed, thanks for the game.

Peter! Please take note of the following Heroes of Might and Magic players in the FB-2 Tournament for the Winter Rating.

Aldegir (Red, Tower, Niela, Niela) lose to Medium_HP (Blue, Stronghold, Kreg Heg, Kreg Heg), 2sm4d(3), 115
Javdet (Red, Castle, Valeska, Charna) def. Wlk777 (Blue, Fortress, Vistan, Vistan), panic, 136
numOne (Blue, Fortress, Vistan, Vistan) lose to Piterius (Red, Rampart, Kirr, Kirr), 2sm4d(3), 123
Javdet (Red, Fortress, Tazar, Clavius) def. Piterius (Blue, Castle, Valeska, Valeska), 2sm4d(3), 133
numOne (Red, Castle, Valeska, Mephala) lose to Aldegir (Blue, Rampart, Kirr, Kirr), balance, 147
Aldegir (Red, Castle, Valeska, Valeska) lose to Wlk777 (Blue, Fortress, Vistan, Vistan), 2sm4d(3), 237
Javdet (Red, Tower, Ain, Nimbus) lose to Aldegir (Blue, Castle, Valeska, Xy), panic, 146
Piterius (Red, Castle, Valeska, Valeska) draw with Aldegir (Blue, Dungeon, Shakti, Shakti), 2sm4d(3), 246
Wlk777 (Red, Stronghold, Gurnisson, Gurnisson) lose to numOne (Blue, Castle, Valeska, Vidomina), 2sm4d(3), 134
numOne (Red, Castle, Valeska, Aislinn) lose to Javdet (Blue, Rampart, Kirr, Kirr), 2sm4d(3), 211
Wlk777 (Red, Fortress, Vistan, Vistan) lose to Medium_HP (Blue, Conflux, Fyr, Gunnar), 2sm4d(3), 131
numOne (Blue, Conflux, Ciel, Dessa) def. Mizrael (Red, Dungeon, Shakti, Shakti), balance, 141

Thanks everyone for the info!

I've updated the ranking table. Everything up to the end of the season has been included, except for unconfirmed, incorrect, disputed games and several tournaments (FB-2, 2010, Novichok).

The following winter season games have not been confirmed:
12/13/2009, 10:40 mals (red, swamp, Wistan, Tazar) def temofey (blue, Castle, Valeska, Valeska) 215,2sm4d(3)
01/03/2010, 21:31 wariator (blue, Barbarian, Crag) def Quell (red, Inferno, Pyre) 2sm4d(3), 134
01/07/2010, 16:17 zloy_romantik (Blue, Rampart, Kirr, Kirr) def Geroinya (Red, Castle, Valya, Valya) 2sm4d(3), 135
01/17/2010, 00:19 cannabis (blue rampart kirr) def VeselchakU(red castle valeska) 2sm4d(3) 116
01/28/2010, Wlk777 (blue, Swamp, Wistan) def temofey(red, Castle, Valeska) 2smd4(3) 132
02/08/2010, RomarioGrom (red, Rampart, Kirya, Kirya) def NcArhAngel (blue, Castle, Valya, Valya) 2sm4d(3) 135
02/20/2010 Lider1 (blue, Dungeon, Shakti, Shakti) def Doz (red, Inferno, Marius, Marius) 8MM6a 136
02/24/2010 DC87 (Blue, Rampart, Kyrre) draw RomarioGrom (Red, Fortress, Wystan, Tazar+Luna) 8MM6a 133
02/27/2010 DC87 (red, Rampart, Kyrre) def Kecalkoatl (blue, Stronghold, Crag) 8mm6а, 235

temofey, according to rule /topic/at/281142/

03/12/09.
Point 1.2 has been supplemented with an explanation of the principles for confirming reports:
I. After a report is published on the forum, the winner is advised to send a link to this report to their opponent via ICQ for confirmation (it is advisable to save these logs).
II. If a player cannot confirm the report in the relevant thread for any reason, they must contact the seasonal games administrator and confirm the report by other means (private message, ICQ, etc.).
III. If a player has outstanding unconfirmed reports about lost games, all subsequent reports from that player will not be counted until the debts are settled.
IV. If a player's one report is not confirmed, and at least a formal reason for non-confirmation is indicated (investigation of unfair play), then reports about the victories of this player will continue to be counted.

Geroinya might still confirm it?

RomarioGrom probably didn't notice the report...

The rest who haven't confirmed, please send a link to this post in ICQ...

I want to do "some statistics", so I ask you to provide complete and accurate information in the reports.
Personally, I don't care who/with whom/on what/how much played, but I don't want to put things randomly, after all, we need to get an objective picture, and not just roll a dice...

01/20/2010, Javdet (red, Castle, random) def Van (blue, Tower, random) balance 131 +++
01/20/2010, Javdet (blue, Tower, random, Galtran) lose Van (red, Dungeon, random, Grindan) 2sm4d(3), 136 +++
01/20/2010, Javdet (red, Swamp, random) def Van (blue, Rampart, random, Enova) 2sm4d(3), 111 +++
Roman! Something is wrong with the heroes here...
Let it be Gosha (in one of the games he definitely was) - there is no time or desire to extract saves. The main thing is that there is a result and confirmation from both sides..

Based on the results, I can only calculate ratings; for this, Javdet def Van is enough.
Since summer, we have been awarding the Best Players for castles, and it would also be interesting to look at statistics by heroes, so I am clarifying the castles and heroes.
In these three reports, I don't understand where the error is, in the castle or hero. Maybe you, Roma, played as Necropolis, not as Tower? And how did Grindan appear in the Dungeon? Also, one loss/win may matter for nomination.

Next, regarding colors - it would be interesting to compare the win/loss statistics of red/blue on different maps.
Please remember and rewrite correctly:

01/01/2010, 21:29 01/02/2010 Shamys (castle, Orrin, Christian) def ReneDekart (necro, Aislinn, Charna) 73 2sm4d(3) SOD - player colors are not indicated, and what does 73 mean?
01/04/2010, Deriel_Linch (tower, Solmyr, Solmyr) def BA/IEHOK (fortress, Tazar, Tazar), 2sm4d(3), 145 +++
01/04/2010, Deriel_Linch (Inferno, Pyra, Luna) def Ellina (Stronghold, Crag Hack, Crag Hack), 2sm4d(3), 212 +++
01/04/2010, XL' (Rampart, Kirr, Kirr) def Ellina (Castle, Valeska, Valeska), 2sm4d(3), 132 +++
02/07/2010, GoD (tower, Torosar, Torosar) def wiggle8509 (dungeon, Shakti, Shakti) 125 2sm4d(3) +++
02/20/2010 GoD (castle, Turis) def theShevanesian (fortress, Tazar) 2sm4d(3), 146 +++
02/24/2010, ReneDekart (tower, Torosar)(Torosar) def Dima Surmay (conflux, Luna)(Luna) 2sm4d(3) 134 +++
02/25/2010 Los(Castle,Valeska,Xarfax) def Sevan_80(Inferno,Ignat,Ignat),2sm4d(3),136 +++
02/28/2010 GoD (Tower, Torosar, Torosar) def StickyFingaz (Inferno, Marius, Galtran) 2sm4d(3) 123 +++
- no colors.

02/07/2010 GoD(red, Fortress, Tazar, Tazar) def wiggle8509(blue, Stronghold, Crag Hack, Crag Hack) 114 +++
02/24/2010 tenyu bezdomnoy (blue, Necropolis, Galtran) def zloy_romantik (red, Conflux, random=Moner) 125 +++
- map templates are not indicated

Based on the results, I can only calculate the rankings; for this, Javdet def Van is sufficient.
We have been awarding the Best players for castles since summer, and it would also be interesting to see statistics for heroes, so I am clarifying the castles and heroes.
In these three reports, I don't understand where the error is, whether it's in the castle or the hero. Maybe you, Roma, were playing as Necropolis and not as Tower? And how did Grindan appear in the Dungeon? Also, a single loss/win can be significant for the nomination.

I can't remember – we played consecutively, and the saves with the nickname "Van" overlapped – only the last game's save remains.

02/24/2010 homeless shadow (blue, Necropolis, Galtran) def zloy_romantik (red, Conflux, random=Moner) 125 +++
- templates not specified

sorry, my mistake :smile41: it was an SM

02/24/2010 homeless shadow (blue, Necropolis, Galtran) def zloy_romantik (red, Conflux, random=Moner) 2sm4d(3) 125 +++

was not activated, so at least with a delay...

Lider1 (blue, dangeon, Shakti, Shakti) def Doz (red, inferno, Marius, Marius) 8MM6a 136

Played without neutral stacks.

On the first week, cats in the Citadel, didn't have enough money for Minotaurs. Secondary skill Fort Necro. Repelled +1 to speed.

On the second week, took secondary skill Ramp. At my respawn, I go into a Troglodyte Conservatory, it's max, but there's a Blasphemy, I take it, they killed the entire stack of Troglodytes except for half a stack. Literally the next turn, I go into the next one, also Troglodyte, thought it was 2-3 for some reason, again max! wow, in short, they killed everything, even 1 Angel. But 7 Angels is good. Went into the secondary Necro, took a Nagabank, visited, university.

On the third week, another Conservatory, mini, damn(, Hive mini, but took the Cloak of Denial and Shackles of War. Well, alright, I think, time to go visit. Basically, I was searching for the opponent, picked up another tree along the way, also mini, at his respawn on 135, and there's a Conservatory, didn't bother to scout, untouched, I go in again, max! very very good.

On 136, I catch up with the opponent's main hero, who just barely didn't make it into his Castle, but 12 Angels and Shackles did the job.

Thank you for the game!

That was the case! Hopefully, there will be more as well)

02/08/2010, RomarioGrom (red, Rampart, Kirya, Kirya) def NcArhAngel (blue, Castle, Valya, Valya) 2sm4d(3) 135 confirmed.

02/24/2010 DC87 (Blue, Rampart, Kyrre) drew RomarioGrom (Red, Fortress, Wystan, Tazar+Luna) 8MM6a 133

I confirm, I didn't even know he existed.

Peter! Please note the following Heroes players in the Sergeant Tournament for the Winter rating: 01/09/2010, Mizrael (blue, Dungeon, Shakti) def. NumOne (red, Castle, Valeska) 2sm4d(3) 221 01/11/2010, Gomunguls (blue, Stronghold, Krag) def. Mizrael (red, Tower, Ain, Jabarkas) 2sm4d(3) 147

By the way, yes.

02/10/2010, BA/IEHOK (blue, Castle, Valerica, Valerica) def Tolikandro (red, Swamp, Vesper, Moner), 2sm4d(3), 141

02/15/2010, BA/IEHOK (red, Castle, Valerica, Shakti) def Pradromalo (blue, Conflux, random, Luna), 2sm4d(3), 135

02/15/2010, XL' (blue, Castle, Caitlin, Caitlin) def KillerVampire (red, Stronghold, Dessa, Gurnisson) 2smd4(3), 135

02/21/2010, XL' (red, Stronghold, Crag Hack, Crag Hack) def BA/IEHOK (blue, Fortress, Tazar, Tazar) 2smd4(3), 216

02/27/2010, XL' (blue, Rampart, Kirr, Moner) def Deriel_Linch (red, Tower, Solmyr, Solmyr) 2smd4(3), 223

It happened, I confirm.

Deriel_Linch (Red, Tower, Solmyr, Solmyr) def BA/IEHOK (Blue, Fortress, Tazar, Tazar), 2sm4d(3), 145

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Deriel_Linch (Red, Inferno, Pyra, Luna) def Ellina (Blue, Stronghold, Kreg Hack, Kreg Hack), 2sm4d(3), 212

DC87 (red, Rampart, Kyrre) def Kecalkoatl (blue, Citadel, Crag) 8mm6а, 235

DC87 (red, Rampart, Kyrre) def Kecalkoatl (blue, Citadel, Crag) 8mm6a, 235

Added 5 minutes later

DCDC (red, Rampart, Kyrre) def Kecalkoatl (blue, Citadel, Crag) 8mm6a, 235

it really happened, I swear.

Please include the following games from the 2010 tournaments in the winter rating.

Redwhait(red, Rampart, Urfetin, Kyr) def KillerVampire(blue, Castle, Edrik, Sorsha, ??) 2sm4d(3) 131

LeBron (red, Barbarian, Hydr, Ignissa) def Logistik (blue, Castle, Christian, Moner) 121 2sm4d(3)

FAVorite ( blue, Dungeon, Loreley, Dice) def Aldegir (red, Castle, Rion, Edrik) 141, 2sm4d(3)

LeBron (blue, Castle, Christian, Gunnar) def wariator (red, Inferno, Ash, Pir) 132

but4er(red, Stronghold, Zubin, Shiva) def BadCat (blue, Dungeon, Jaegar, Gunar) 1-4-4, 8mm6

Alessandro(red, Rampart, Urfetin) def Psyche_7(blue, Castle, Inham, Crag Hack) 1-2-3, 2sm4d(3)

Van (Red, Castle, Valeska, Torosar) def RiMpel2 (Blue, Rampart, Kyrre, Tomika) 144, 2sm4d(3)

Pit for LM (blue, Stronghold, Oris, Pyra) def SEM_56 (red, Dungeon, Loreley, Tazar), 2sm4d(3), 126.

Aldegir( blue, Castle, Rion, Pyra) def злой_романтик(red, Dungeon, Loreley, Loreley ) 113, 2sm4d(3)

Aldegir( red, Castle, Rion, Kyrre) def Деконтаминатор(blue, Fortress, Verdish, Gunnar ) 122, 2sm4d(3)

Redwhait(red, Barbarian, Yog, Grindan) def Mizrael(blue, Castle, Edrik, Tyraxor) 8mm6 217

KillerVampire(red, Fortress, Tiva, Dragon) def Loi(blue, Castle, Sonya, Gundula) 2sm4d(3) 126

KobRa (blue, Castle, Valeska, Wystan) def but4er (red, Stronghold, Tyraxor, Tyraxor) on 8MM6 @ 141

Loi(red, castle, Edrik, Dessa) def redwhait(blue, strong, Oris, Klavius) 2sm4d(3) 115

FireToSky (blue, Dungeon, Loreley, Labeta) def Loi (red, Rampart, Urfetin, Kyrre), 2sm4d(3), 132

Looser (red, Castle, Sonya, Turis) def RomarioGrom (blue, Necropolis, Nimbus, Tant) 2sm4d(3) 222

Hermit(red, inferno, Axis, Pyre) def злой романтик(blue, Dungeon, Loreley, Das) 8mm6 217

SEM_56 (blue, Swamp, Verdish, Alkin) def mals (red, Dungeon, Loreley, Vokial) 2sm4d(3), 125

LeBron (blue, Barbarian, Zubin, Moner) def RomarioGrom (red, Inferno, Ash, Tazar) 143 2sm4d(3)

Hermit(blue, Castle, Rion, Broghild) def Деконтоминатор(red, Stronghold, Gerda, Charna) balance 135

Looser (red, Dungeon, Loreley, Crag Hack) def wariator (blue, Stronghold, Oris, Gundulla) 2sm4d(3) 143

FAVorite (Red, Fortress, Voi, Tazar) def Злой романтик (Blue, Castle, Rion, Christian) 2sm4d3 137

Van (Blue, Stronghold, Oris, Orin) def Lider1 (Red, Tower, Pikendram, Crag Heck) 112, 2sm4d(3)

Logisti k (red, Rampart, Urfetin, Mephala) def RomarioGrom ( blue, Dungeon, Loreley, Das) 145 2sm4d(3)

but4er(red, Inferno, Fiona, Fiona) def MatrosOFF(blue, Necropolis, Galtran, Galtran), 8mm6, 124

Van (Red, Stronghold, Oris, Crag Heck) def AYMAN (Blue, Swamp, Tiva, Tazar) 122, 2sm4d(3)

Эрдэм (Red, Dungeon, random, Alamar, Aenain) def Deriel_Linch (Blue, Castle, random, Inham, Dessa), 2sm4d(3), 126

Hermit(red, Dungeon, Loreley, Loreley) draw Aldegir(blue, Castle, Rion, Aiden) balance 137

mals(blue, Castle, Rion, Vokial) def KoстяN(red, Swamp, Voy, Christian) 142

Captain (blue, Castle, Rion, Pasis) def Stizko(red, Tower, Piguedram, Riza) 134 Balance

Blackpoint (blue, castle, Rion) def Rebellious (red, Necropolis, Stracer) 211 8mm6

Captain (blue, Barbarian, Oris, Jabarkas) def scorp(red, Dungeon, Jaegar, Alkin) 211 2sm4d(3)

AYMAN (blue, swamp, Verdish, Dragon) def RiMpel2 (red, castle, Rion, Terek) 2sm4d(3), 125

wowa (blue, Rampart, Urfetin, Ivor) def Volland (Stronghold, Oris, Monere) 224, 8MM6@средние дороги, TE-full

FAVorite (red, Fortress, Tiva, Bron) def Hermit (blue, Dungeon, Loreley, Loreley) 8mm6 232

Logisti k (red, Barbarian, Oris, Marius) def wariator (blue, Dungeon, Loreley, Fafner) 126 2sm4(d)3

SEM_56 (blue, Stronghold, Oris, Gurnisson) def КостяN (red, Castle, Rion, Orrin) 2sm4d(3) 132

Wic (red, Tower, Serena, Neela) def Volland (blue, Conflux, Aenain, CragHack) @ 8mm6a, 125

FAVorite (blue, Castle, Rion, Andra) draw Деконтоминатор (red, Tower, Pikuedram, Pyra) 8mm6 131

RomarioGrom (blue, Swamp, Stig, Stig) def wariator (red, Stronghold, Zubin, Gunnar) 2sm4d(3) 235

Forrest (red, dungeon, Jeddit, Crag Hack) def Sil (Conflux, Aenain, Tazar) 1-4-7 Jebus Cross TE full

XL' (blue, tower, pikedram, caitlin) def rebellious (red, inferno, axis, pir), 8mm6, 146

Forrest (blue swamp Broghild) def Javdet(inferno fiona) 1-2-4 Jebus Cross

Psyche_7(blue, Rampart, Ufretin, Solmyr) def Kash(red, Castle, Rion, Lacus), 127, 8mm6

Эрдэм (Blue, Dungeon, Shakti, Shakti) def Gomunguls (Red, Swamp, Alkin, Alkin), 2sm4d(3), 114

Psyche_7(blue, Dungeon, Damacon, Galthran) def Soroka(red, Necropolis, Straker, Clavius), 147, 2sm4d(3)

Alessandro(blue, castle, Rion, Turis) def Kash (red, inferno, Zidar, Ignatius), 8mm6, 117

Kash (blue, Necropolis, Straker, Nagash) lose Avern (red, castle, Rion, Ivor), 2sm4d(3), 132

scorp (blue, Rampart, Urfetin, Ivor) def Stizko (red, Stronghold, Oris, Vidomina) 8mm6, 135

besha(castle random Valeska red) def Forrest(barb Tiraksor Tiraksor blue) 147 8mm6

XL' (red, Inferno, Rashka, Moner) def blackpoint (blue, Stronghold, Oris, Crag Hack), 2sm4(d)3, 213

AliaSmehova(castle, Sanya, Shacti, red) def Van(Dungeon, Loreley, Pyrre, blue) 127, 2sm4d(3).

Captain(Barbarian, Oris, Tiraksor, red) def outlaw(Tower, Piguedram, Piguedram, blue) 115, 2sm4d(3).

Psyche_7(red, Dungeon, Lorelei, Inteus) def Avern(blue, Castle, Ingham, Marius), balance, 211

Дубровин Павел (Red, Fortress, Tazar, Tazar) def Эрдэм (Blue, Dungeon. Shakti, Shakti), 2sm4d(3), 2.1.7.

Lider1 (blue, fortress, Verdish, Tazar) def RiMpel2 (red, stronghold, Orris, Jabarkas) Balance 113

OUTLAW(blue, Dungeon, Lora, Dimer) def Scorp(red, Swamp, Verdish, Grindan), 2sm4d(3), 1-1-5

Pit for LM (red, Stronghold, Oris, Moner) def КостяN (blue, Castle, Rion, Gunnar), 2sm4d(3), 134.

Gomunguls(Red, Castle, Rion, Enova) def Дубровин Павел(Blue, Rampart, Urfetin, Dessa) 2sm4d(3), 1.3.1

bRitvo4kA (red, Stronghold, Oris, Orrin) def XL' (blue, Dungeon, Geon, Tazar), 2smd4(3), 135

Volland (red, Barbarian, ogre spec, Tiraksor) def Alone (blue, castle, Orin, Turis), TE, 8mm6, 116

Pit for LM (blue, Fortress, Verdish, Alkin) def mals (red, Stronghold, Oris, Crag), 2sm4d(3), 215.

wowa (Dungeon, Lorelei) def Alone (Fortress, Styg, Tazar), TE-full, 143@Ностальгия

Soroka (red, Castle, Rion, Rion) def Kash (blue, Necropolis, Straker, Straker), 2sm4d(3), 113

OUTLAW(blue, Castle, Rion, Gunnar) def SpiriTT(red, Swamp, Voya, Gurnisson), 2SM4d(3), 2-2-7

Alessandro(red, Dungeon, Geon, Gunnar) def Avern(blue, Swamp, Tiva, Ain) 115, 2sm4d(3)

Gomunguls(Blue, Castle, Turis, Turis) def Deriel_Linch(Red, Tower, Josephine, Tazar) 2SM4d(3 ) 1.3.2

OUTLAW(red, Swamp, Verdish, Nimus) DRAW Stizko(blue, Castle, Rion, Nella), 8mm6, 1-4-6

Captain(Red, Necropolis, Straker, Straker) def SpiriTT(Blue, Barbarian, Oris, Jabarkas) 2SM4d(3 ) 1.4.4

Wic (blue, Stronghold, Gird, Jabarkas) def Wowa (red, Necropolis, Straker, Silvia + Galthran) @ Nostalgia, 2.2.4

Mizrael(Dungeon, Lorelei, Lorelei) def Loi(red, Rampart, Ufretin, Ivor) balance 127

Javdet (blue, Rampart, Kyrre, Kyrre) def Piterius (red, Dungeon, Shackty, Shackty) 8mm6 212

PReDS(red, Inferno, Olema, Tazar) def wowa(blue, Rampart, Urfetin, Tiraxon/Gunnar), Nostalgia, 146.

Soroka (blue, Dungeon, Loreley, Loreley) def Alessandro (red, Castle, Rion, Rion), 2sm4d(3), 114

Blackpoint (blue, Castle, Rion, Galtran) def Prodromalo (red, Stronghold, Oris, Gurnison) 236 2sm4d(3)

PReDS(blue, Barbarian, Gird, Terek) lose Wicc(red, Tower, Daremif, Gunnar), 8XM12a, 136

KobRa(blue, castle, Valya) def Satyr(red, Rampart, Ivor), 8MM6, 117

Logisti k (red, Sanya, Brissa, Torosar) def Looser (blue, Rampart, Urfetin, Ivor) 126 2sm4d(3)

Mizrael(blue, Fortress, Verdish, Neela) def KillerVampire(red, Stronghold, Yog, Tiraksor) 8mm6 134

bRitvo4kA (Stronghold, blue, Oris, Valeska) def Pradromalo (Castle, red, Rion, Orrin), 2smd4(3), 133

злой_романтик (Red, Castle, Valya, Valya) draw Деконтаминатор (Blue, Rampart, Kyrre, Kyrre) 2smd4(3), 143

bRitvo4kA (Tower, blue, Piguedram, Gundula) def Blackpoint (Inferno, red, Axil, Marius), Balance, 124

LeBron (red, castle, Rion, Galtran/Klavius) draw Looser (blue, Fortress, Verdash, Alkin/Charna) 2sm4d(3), 143

Forrest (red strong tirasiko) draw Piterius (Rampart kyrre) 117 Jebus Cross

rebellious (red, Tower, Serena, Rissa ) def Pradromalo (blue, Rion, Tyris), 8mm6, 231

rebellious (blue, Necropolis, Straker, Tamika ) def bRitvo4kA (red, Castle, Rion, Christian), 8mm6, 235