Auto-translated
1 — 4, I would have kept the coins for myself, but the appearance isn't repulsive, so I'll leave it as is.
2 — 8, it doesn't resonate with me on an emotional level, but overall it's good; I can afford to rate it a bit higher for the contest.
3 — 8, I thought about using it in one of the expansions, but the opportunity never arose; I don't like the armor (not that it's bad, just that it doesn't interest me), but I like the overall image.
4 — 6, it seems like out of all the alchemists, I liked this one the most, but in this particular entry, that's not a huge achievement + the artwork itself doesn't evoke any emotions.
5 — 9, so here we have: gentle hands ✔️, hair that smells like summer ?, a clear, lively voice ?, doesn't judge ???, you just lean in and touch your lips (hopefully not, otherwise I'll have to deduct a point or two) ?, a hint of sadness in her eyes ✔️, curiosity about the world around her ?. Well, 2/7 is also okay. I like the concept (at least in the way I see it).
6 — naa 10, you could nitpick about the drawing style, the angle, and some minor details, but real men don't do that.
7 — 6, I'm rating it without the head.
8 — 5, no way.
9 — 6, I don't like the ears, and the clothes are also 0, but overall it's acceptable.
10 — ∞, there were many candidates for this contest, but I settled on this one because the emotional response is very strong and warms both my heart and soul, and also, "objectively," it's very well drawn.
11 — 7, the combination of eye color and hair isn't quite to my taste, but overall it's good.
12 — 9, nice.
13 — 6, I can't quite grasp the drawing style; it seems cool, but also somehow not quite right.
14 — 6, I'm rating it without the head.
15 — 9, nice.