Posts from Heroes with the required skill.

Often, while playing, you need to remember a hero who has a particular useful skill. To this end, I decided to compile a list of heroes who are used in various situations. The structure was based on the fact that first, the necessary, most frequently used skills for primary and secondary heroes were identified. The advantage of this scheme over existing programs is that if, for example, we are interested in the Tactics skill, we can quickly find all suitable heroes using the scheme.

Logistics
Kirr	Rampart
Dessa	Stronghold
Gunnar	Dungeon
Pir	Inferno
Moner	Conflux

Heroes with the corresponding specialization are highlighted in bold.

Scout (pathfinding)
Clancy	Rampart
Gretchin	Stronghold
Korbak	Swamp

Scouting
Aeris	Rampart
Piguegram	Tower
Fiona (+2)	Inferno
Kalh	Inferno
Lorelei	Dungeon
Deemer	Dungeon
Shiva	Stronghold
Brokhild	Swamp

Navigation
Sylvia	Castle
Voy	Swamp

First Aid
Rion	Castle
Jem	Rampart
Verdish	Swamp

Tactics
Tyris	Castle
Torosar	Tower
Charna	Necropolis
Tyraxor	Stronghold
Terek	Stronghold
Shakti	Dungeon
Deis	Dungeon
Gunnar	Dungeon
Ignatius	Inferno
Tunar	Conflux
Lakussa (+2)	Conflux
Erdamon	Conflux
Kalt	Conflux

Diplomacy
Adel	Castle
Roland	Rampart
Sarah	Tower

Artillery (war machine)
Pir	Inferno
Arlash	Dungeon
Gurnisson	Stronghold
Gervulf	Swamp
Christian	Castle
Torosar *	Tower
Zubin	Stronghold
Vokial	Necropolis
Passissa	Conflux
Ignissa	Conflux

Heroes who start with a ballista are highlighted in bold.
Heroes who do not have the corresponding starting skill are marked with an asterisk (*).

Literacy (scholar)
Ain	Tower
Koronius	Rampart
Rashka	Inferno
Xiron	Inferno
Alamar	Dungeon
Octavia	Inferno
Synka	Dungeon
Tan (+2)	Tower
Nella	Tower
Fawner	Tower
Iona	Tower
Septinna	Necropolis

Heroes who start with the Wisdom skill are highlighted in bold.

+350 gold
Caitlin	Castle
Enova	Rampart
Ain	Tower
Octavia	Inferno
Damacon	Dungeon
Clavius	Necropolis
Nagash	Necropolis
Jelar	Conflux
Grindan	Conflux

+1 resource
Rizza +1 mercury	Tower
Kalid +1 sulfur	Inferno
Sephingorf +1 crystal	Dungeon
Saurug +1 gem	Stronghold

Magic of Earth
Labeta	Conflux
Grindan	Conflux

Magic of Air
Brissa	Conflux
Aenain	Conflux

Magic of Fire
Luna	Conflux
Inteus	Conflux

Magic of Water
Ciel	Conflux
Jelar	Conflux

Notes.
1) "+2" means that the specified skill in the hero is at the "advanced" stage.

Dear vbn, what about Christian from the Castle?

Dear VBN, why haven't you paid attention to heroes with "innate" earth, air, fire, and water magic? Or is it a secret to you that, with a certain "setup," you might not even get the "right" secondary skill.
Or do you think such heroes are useless?!
There's a great map called First Blad. It really needs a hero with scouting skills.
If you're going to do something, do it all the way, my friend, finish it properly, or don't do it at all.
And you should have named the topic "heroes with a specific skill and secondary ability," since that's what you're talking about.

Sincerely

You're being too hasty...
Firstly, as I understand it, the topic isn't finished and will be expanded as new ideas and suggestions from forum members are received.
Secondly, even if your complaint is taken as a suggestion, the topic won't end there...
Thirdly, could you be a little more modest? It would be better if you bragged about how you named your second son and what his characteristics are (height, weight).

There's still a lot to come! I'll definitely brag about it later.

Read the preface more carefully, Alex_R, and you'll understand that this is a complete work (at least in terms of meaning).
As for the comment, I think everything is appropriate. VBN, as I understand it, is not a beginner, and if he decides to teach, guide, or help someone, he needs to do it more thoroughly.
If he is a beginner, then such criticism is too harsh for him.
It seems to me that the physics of the Heroes world is the best helper for anyone.

I'm sorry, but why are you making a distinction between online and offline? You should pay attention to the section where you placed the topic. And in that case, what does your recognition or non-recognition of a particular hero have to do with offline play? Heroes with their specialties and secondary skills don't require anyone's recognition. In my opinion, you need to systematize them better. After all, you are preparing a cheat sheet for all games in general, or am I mistaken?

If you want, VBN, I can help you sort out this complex issue. I keep criticizing, so let's do something constructive. You can retain authorship. It's a good idea, aimed at categorizing all heroes not by castles (as in the "PHYSICS" game), but by specialties and primary skills. This work could be helpful to many.
Sincerely,

I believe it’s necessary to continue our discussion in a private message, where I will later explain my thoughts on what you consider to be a “simple” issue. For everyone to see, I will say that after such a long time since the game’s initial release, there simply cannot be any “simple” things left in Heroes 3, as you should be aware of how much has already been written and rewritten on this topic over that time. Therefore, even if your work is somewhat similar to something that already exists, it should at least be made beautiful and carefully considered multiple times. Sincerely.

Dear Dmitry_A_S and vbn! Please refrain from moving your conversation to private messages. The content of your discussion helps to better understand Heroes 3...

The idea... is aimed at categorizing all heroes not by castle (as in Heroes of Might and Magic), but by specialization and primary skills.

I'll be so bold as to disagree :) Heroes of Might and Magic categorizes heroes based on absolutely any criteria... :) Technically, it's much faster to do this in Excel than in a text file - just two mouse clicks...

I primarily meant the basic principle of gradation (a separate gradation, like in VBN, which you don't have).
And no one is arguing that you can find absolutely everything quickly on the FIZMIG website.

Deemer also has +2.